Water Filter Pitchers (and Faucet Mounts)
Point-of-use (POU) granular activated carbon (GAC) water filter pitchers and faucet mounted filters are a popular, affordable solution for improving drinking water quality in homes. These filters, such as those from brands like Brita or PUR, use GAC to enhance taste and remove specific contaminants at the point of consumption, making them ideal for renters or small households.
What Are Activated Carbon Filters?
Water pitcher filters utilize what's called activated carbon—a highly porous material derived from sources like coconut shells, coal, or wood—to remove contaminants from water. The carbon is "activated" through a heating process that creates a vast network of microscopic pores, providing a large surface area (up to 1000 m²/g) for adsorption.
While these filters can also be found in point-of-entry whole home filters, they are most commonly found in the water pitcher filter or tap-mounted form.
How It works:
Activated carbon filters operate through adsorption, where contaminants bind to the carbon’s porous surface as water passes through. This process traps organic compounds, chlorine, and some heavy metals, improving water taste and safety.
Unlike reverse osmosis (RO), which removes up to 99.99% of total dissolved solids (TDS) via a semi-permeable membrane, activated carbon filters do not significantly reduce dissolved inorganics or microorganisms, limiting their scope but simplifying maintenance and reducing waste.
Granular Activated Carbon (GAC) consists of loose carbon granules packed into a cartridge or bed, allowing water to flow through with minimal resistance.
Water passes through the granules, adsorbing contaminants onto their surfaces. The loose structure enables high flow rates but offers less contact time, reducing efficiency for some contaminants. The major benefits with a GAC filter is its accessibility and affordability -- often found as common household filter pitchers. However, GAC is less effective for heavy metals (e.g., lead, mercury) or complex contaminants compared to carbon block.
Contaminant Removal Capabilities
Activated carbon filters excel at removing organic compounds, chlorine, and some heavy metals but are less effective than RO for dissolved inorganics, microorganisms, and certain heavy metals. See a list of contaminants that activated charcoal systems can assist with:
Contaminant | Can Carbon Block Help? | Explanation |
---|---|---|
1,1 Dichloroethane | Yes | VOC, effectively removed by carbon block due to dense structure. |
1,1 Dichloroethylene | Yes | VOC, certified under NSF/ANSI 53 for carbon block. |
1,1 Dichloropropene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective due to longer contact time. |
1,1,1 Trichloroethane | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
1,1,1,2 Tetrachloroethane | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
1,1,2 Trichloroethane | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
1,1,2,2 Tetrachloroethane | Yes | VOC, effectively removed by carbon block. |
1,2 Dichlorobenzene | Yes | VOC, certified under NSF/ANSI 53 for carbon block. |
1,2 Dichloroethane | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
1,2 Dichloropropane | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
1,2,3 Trichlorobenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
1,2,3 Trichloropropane | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
1,2,4 Trichlorobenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
1,2,4 Trimethylbenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
1,3 Dichlorobenzene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
1,3 Dichloropropane | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
1,3 Dichloropropene | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
1,3,5 Trimethylbenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
1,4 Dichlorobenzene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
2,2 Dichloropropane | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Aluminum | Partial | Carbon block may reduce some forms. |
Antimony | Partial | Carbon block certified for some reduction. |
Arsenic | Partial | Carbon block may reduce As(V). |
Benzene | Yes | VOC, certified under NSF/ANSI 53 for carbon block. |
Bromobenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
Bromochloromethane | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Bromodichloromethane | Yes | THM, certified for carbon block. |
Bromoform | Yes | THM, certified for carbon block. |
Bromomethane | Partial | Volatile gas, partial removal by carbon block. |
Cadmium | Partial | Carbon block certified for some reduction. |
Carbon Tetrachloride | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Chlorobenzene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Chloroethane | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Chloroform | Yes | THM, certified for carbon block. |
Chloromethane | Partial | Volatile gas, partial removal by carbon block. |
Chlorotoluene 2 | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
Chlorotoluene 4 | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
Chromium (Total) | Partial | Carbon block certified for some Cr(VI) reduction. |
cis 1,2 Dichloroethylene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Copper | Partial | Carbon block certified for some reduction. |
Dibromochloromethane | Yes | THM, certified for carbon block. |
Dibromochloropropane | Yes | Pesticide, certified for carbon block. |
Dibromomethane | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Dichlorodifluoromethane | Partial | Volatile gas, partial removal by carbon block. |
Dichloromethane | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Ethylbenzene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Ethylene dibromide | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Hexachlorobutadiene | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
Hydrogen Sulfide (H2S) Gas Strip | Yes | Gas, effectively removed by carbon block. |
Iron | Partial | Carbon block may reduce some forms. |
Isopropylbenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Lead | Partial | Carbon block certified under NSF/ANSI 53 for reduction. |
m,p Xylene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Manganese | Partial | Carbon block may reduce some forms. |
Mercury | Partial | Carbon block certified for some reduction. |
Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
n Butylbenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
n Propylbenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Naphthalene | Yes | VOC, carbon block outperforms GAC. |
o Xylene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
p Isopropyltoluene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
sec Butylbenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Silver | Partial | Carbon block may reduce some forms. |
Styrene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
tert Butylbenzene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Tetrachloroethylene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Toluene Petroleum Compounds | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Total THMs | Yes | Disinfection byproducts, certified for carbon block. |
trans 1,3 Dichloropropene | Yes | VOC, carbon block more effective. |
Trichloroethylene | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Trichlorofluoromethane | Partial | Volatile gas, partial removal by carbon block. |
Turbidity | Partial | Carbon block reduces fine particles (0.5–5 microns). |
Vinyl Chloride | Yes | VOC, certified for carbon block. |
Zinc | Partial | Carbon block certified for some reduction. |
Additional Water Filter Pitcher Considerations:
GAC pitchers and faucet mounts are effective for basic needs but have limitations:
-
Effectiveness: They focus on organics and chlorine but not inorganics or microorganisms, like RO’s capabilities.
-
Maintenance: Filters must be replaced regularly to avoid saturation or bacterial growth, with POU systems requiring more frequent changes (2–6 months for GAC pitchers).
-
Costs: Point of use (POU) systems including pitchers cost $20–$140 with $20–$160 annual maintenance for replacement filters.
- Environmental Impact: Unlike RO, which produces significant wastewater (3–5 gallons per gallon filtered), activated carbon filters generate minimal waste, primarily from filter replacements, and reduce bottled water use, lowering plastic waste.